New Milford, NJ
Real Estate Market Report
Updated October 2026
NYC commute from New Milford
Peak-hour estimates to Midtown. Times vary by station and schedule.
Rail, PATH, bus, or ferry
Pascack Valley Line
Transit to Midtown
48 min
Peak drive to Midtown
35 min
Nearest station
New Milford Station · 0.3 mi
36
Active Listings
34
Sold (3 months)
$750,857
Avg Sale Price
$699,000
Median Sale Price
$830,143
Avg List Price
N/A
Avg $/Sqft
21
Under Contract
📈 Prices Trending Up
Market Trend
Balanced Market — 3.2 months of inventory
Investment Analysis
Based on tax records, sales trends, and market data
78
Investment Score
Strong Buy
+4%
Price Appreciation
Last 3 months vs prior 3
$4,194
Est. Monthly Rent
Net yield: 5.4%/yr
$13,794
Avg Annual Tax
Median: $12,774.81
This tool is provided solely by Garden State AI and is not a product or service of BHG Green Team Realty. BHG Green Team Realty is not responsible for the accuracy of this AI-generated information.
Stay Ahead of the New Milford Market
Get instant alerts — new listings, price drops, and sold comps in New Milford.
Get Instant Price-Drop & New Listing Alerts in New Milford
Tell us when a New Milford home hits the market or drops in price. Free buyer alerts.
What's Your New Milford Home Worth in 2026?
Get a seller valuation for your New Milford home using recent sales and local tax data.
Recent Sales in New Milford
Last 3 months
SoldSold $680,000
Listed at $699,000
455 Luhmann Drive
Sold: Oct 16, 2026
Listed by: Maureen McSpirit, McSpirit & Beckett Real Estate
Sold by: Samia Dumani, Realty One Group Sunrise
SoldSold $730,000
Listed at $660,000
397 Pleasant Avenue
Sold: Oct 15, 2026
Listed by: Grace Perez, Coldwell Banker, Hillsdale
Sold by: Jaclyn Valenzano, The Agency One Rock-Paramus
SoldSold $578,000
Listed at $550,000
188 Lafayette Avenue
Sold: Oct 13, 2026
Listed by: Emmanuel Pablo, Real
Sold by: Peggy Jung, Coldwell Banker, Ridgewood
SoldSold $699,000
294 Kastler Court
Sold: Oct 9, 2026
Listed by: Elizabeth Ruckdeschel, Coldwell Banker, Hillsdale
Sold by: Kishan Trivedi, Gild Realty
SoldSold $680,000
Listed at $639,000
170 Clinton Avenue
Sold: Oct 9, 2026
Listed by: Emmanuel Martinez, Keller Williams City Views Realty
Sold by: Sara Duarte, Lifestyle International Realty
SoldSold $660,000
Listed at $669,000
1050 Evergreen Court
Sold: Oct 7, 2026
Listed by: Joshua Kim, The Agency One Rock-Fort Lee
Sold by: Joshua Kim, The Agency One Rock-Fort Lee
Homes for Sale in New Milford
36 active listings
Active$1,795,000
329 Birchwood Road
Listed by United Real Estate
Active$1,399,999
191 Rambler Avenue
Listed by Signature Realty NJ LLC
Active$1,399,999
193 Oak Lane
Listed by Signature Realty NJ LLC
Active$1,350,000
627 Concord Street
Listed by ATP Realty Inc.
Active$1,300,000
719 Cypress Street
Listed by Prominent Properties Sotheby's International Realty-Englewood Cliffs
Active$1,299,999
64 Eagle Avenue
Listed by Signature Realty NJ LLC
Own a Home in New Milford?
Find out what it's worth in today's market. Free, instant, no obligation.
Get My Free Home ValuationOr message Vale on WhatsApp: +1 (201) 528-1095