NYC commute from Nutley
Peak-hour estimates to Midtown. Times vary by station and schedule.
Rail, PATH, bus, or ferry
NJ Transit Bus 11
Transit to Midtown
42 min
Peak drive to Midtown
35 min
Nearest station
Nutley (DeCamp Bus) · 1 mi
49
Active Listings
39
Sold (3 months)
$739,273
Avg Sale Price
$711,000
Median Sale Price
$725,017
Avg List Price
N/A
Avg $/Sqft
20
Under Contract
📈 Prices Trending Up
Market Trend
Balanced Market — 3.8 months of inventory
Investment Analysis
Based on tax records, sales trends, and market data
78
Investment Score
Strong Buy
+4%
Price Appreciation
Last 3 months vs prior 3
$4,266
Est. Monthly Rent
Net yield: 5.5%/yr
$13,593
Avg Annual Tax
Median: $12,241.43
This tool is provided solely by Garden State AI and is not a product or service of BHG Green Team Realty. BHG Green Team Realty is not responsible for the accuracy of this AI-generated information.
Stay Ahead of the Nutley Market
Get instant alerts — new listings, price drops, and sold comps in Nutley.
Get Instant Price-Drop & New Listing Alerts in Nutley
Tell us when a Nutley home hits the market or drops in price. Free buyer alerts.
What's Your Nutley Home Worth in 2026?
Get a seller valuation for your Nutley home using recent sales and local tax data.
Recent Sales in Nutley
Last 3 months
SoldSold $715,000
Listed at $749,900
82 Fischer Avenue
Sold: Oct 26, 2026
Listed by: Mary Ryder, Keller Williams Realty - NJ Metro Group
Sold by: Edwin Lora, United Real Estate
SoldSold $650,000
Listed at $599,000
59 Union Avenue
Sold: Oct 22, 2026
Listed by: Nancy Chu, Keller Williams Realty - NJ Metro Group
Sold by: Frenecis Rangel Nava, Lifestyle International Realty
SoldSold $700,000
Listed at $659,000
12 Renner Avenue
Sold: Oct 15, 2026
Listed by: Taghried Louis, Keller Williams Team Realty
Sold by: Taghried Louis, Keller Williams Team Realty
SoldSold $580,000
Listed at $550,000
46 Highland Avenue
Sold: Oct 15, 2026
Listed by: Zachary Sebek, Compass New Jersey, LLC-Montclair
Sold by: Outside Agent, Outside Office
SoldSold $565,000
Listed at $552,000
155 Columbia
Sold: Oct 9, 2026
Listed by: Maryanne Donzi, Weichert Realtors, Fort Lee
Sold by: Outside Agent, Outside Office
SoldSold $660,000
Listed at $675,000
26 Funston Place
Sold: Oct 6, 2026
Listed by: Wilfredo Alfaro, Coldwell Banker, Upper Montclair
Sold by: Lauren Turano, Coldwell Banker, Wayne
Homes for Sale in Nutley
49 active listings
Active$1,299,999
51 Stager Street
Listed by Keller Williams Park Views
Active$1,099,000
90 Grant Avenue
Listed by Coldwell Banker, Upper Montclair
Active$1,050,000
141 Coeyman Avenue
Listed by RE/MAX Professionals 1
Active$1,000,000
51 Albany Avenue
Listed by The Agency One Rock-Montclair
Active$999,000
67 Vreeland Avenue
Listed by Keller Williams Realty - NJ Metro Group
Active$995,000
58 Beech Street
Listed by Realty Executives Elite Homes
Own a Home in Nutley?
Find out what it's worth in today's market. Free, instant, no obligation.
Get My Free Home ValuationOr message Vale on WhatsApp: +1 (201) 528-1095