Old Tappan, NJ
Real Estate Market Report
Updated October 2026
15
Active Listings
14
Sold (3 months)
$1,739,750
Avg Sale Price
$1,630,000
Median Sale Price
$2,396,846
Avg List Price
N/A
Avg $/Sqft
5
Under Contract
📈 Prices Trending Up
Market Trend
Balanced Market — 3.2 months of inventory
Investment Analysis
Based on tax records, sales trends, and market data
77
Investment Score
Strong Buy
+3.5%
Price Appreciation
Last 3 months vs prior 3
$9,780
Est. Monthly Rent
Net yield: 6.1%/yr
$19,787
Avg Annual Tax
Median: $18,234.76
This tool is provided solely by Garden State AI and is not a product or service of BHG Green Team Realty. BHG Green Team Realty is not responsible for the accuracy of this AI-generated information.
Stay Ahead of the Old Tappan Market
Get instant alerts — new listings, price drops, and sold comps in Old Tappan.
Get Instant Price-Drop & New Listing Alerts in Old Tappan
Tell us when a Old Tappan home hits the market or drops in price. Free buyer alerts.
What's Your Old Tappan Home Worth in 2026?
Get a seller valuation for your Old Tappan home using recent sales and local tax data.
Recent Sales in Old Tappan
Last 3 months
SoldSold $3,499,000
Listed at $3,524,888
11 Green Way
Sold: Oct 19, 2026
Listed by: Attilio Adamo, Serhant New Jersey LLC
Sold by: Miriam Lambert, The Agency One Rock-Closter
SoldSold $1,975,000
Listed at $2,199,000
27 Pine Hill Road
Sold: Oct 15, 2026
Listed by: Attilio Adamo, Serhant New Jersey LLC
Sold by: Attilio Adamo, Serhant New Jersey LLC
SoldSold $1,525,000
Listed at $1,699,000
136 Willow Drive
Sold: Oct 9, 2026
Listed by: Attilio Adamo, Serhant New Jersey LLC
Sold by: Dimitrios Kalognomas, Serhant New Jersey LLC
SoldSold $1,630,000
Listed at $1,799,900
1051 Westwood Avenue
Sold: Oct 6, 2026
Listed by: Ryan Sunden, Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty-The Sunden Group
Sold by: Ryan Sunden, Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty-The Sunden Group
SoldSold $1,103,000
Listed at $995,000
11 Haring Drive
Sold: Oct 5, 2026
Listed by: Attilio Adamo, Serhant New Jersey LLC
Sold by: Attilio Adamo, Serhant New Jersey LLC
SoldSold $1,820,000
Listed at $1,850,000
25 Charles Place
Sold: Sep 28, 2026
Listed by: Edward Jablonski, Keller Williams Village Square Realty
Sold by: Su Zheng, EXP Realty, LLC - Englewood Cliffs
Homes for Sale in Old Tappan
15 active listings
Active$3,149,000
19 Dearborn Drive
Listed by Coldwell Banker, Alpine/Closter
Active$2,890,000
7 Orchard Lane
Listed by Serhant New Jersey LLC
Active$2,888,000
312 Old Tappan Road
Listed by Serhant New Jersey LLC
Active$2,795,000
30 FRED Street
Listed by RE/MAX Signature Homes
Active$2,790,000
106 Koch Lane
Listed by Serhant New Jersey LLC
Active$2,788,000
8 Ann Street
Listed by Realmart Realty, LLC
Own a Home in Old Tappan?
Find out what it's worth in today's market. Free, instant, no obligation.
Get My Free Home ValuationOr message Vale on WhatsApp: +1 (201) 528-1095