1 / 5




$850,000
71 Bartholdi Avenue, Butler Borough, NJ, 07405
MLS# 26020345
13
Bedrooms
6
Bathrooms
1
Half Baths
1950
Year Built
Residential — Colonial
Property Type
Description
A truly rare opportunity awaits with this former rectory, offering an extraordinary combination of space, character, and endless possibilities. Rich in history & filled with architectural charm, this one-of-a-kind property provides an impressive layout designed to accommodate a variety of uses. The first floor welcomes you with a gracious entry foyer leading to expansive living and dining room, a large eat in kitchen complete with an oversized pantry, two bedrooms, a full bath, and a spacious family room. Adding to the home's unique appeal is a private chapel, preserving the property's distinctive heritage & creating a remarkable space unlike anything else on the market. The second floor offers exceptional living quarters: five generously sized bedroom suites, each with its own attached sitting area. For those seeking additional sleeping accommodations, the existing layout presents the potential to create up to ten bedrooms by enclosing the sitting areas. Three full bathrooms serve this level. On the third floor you'll find a large unfinished attic with so much potential for storage, expansion, or finishing. The lower level is equally impressive, featuring 8 ft ceilings, a large open recreation room, a summer kitchen, laundry area, and numerous storage rooms. Whether you're seeking a spacious private residence, institutional use, or a property with redevelopment potential, this remarkable property offers unmatched size, flexibility, & opportunity.
Tax & Financial Information
| Listed | June 2, 2026 |
Property Features
Interior
- ✓Heating: Baseboard,Gas,Hot Water
- ✓Basement: Full
Listing Information
Listing Office: Howard Hanna Rand Realty — 973-694-6500
Listing Agent: Cherilyn Ventola — 862-224-9632 — cherilyn.ventola@randrealty.com
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Data provided for consumer's personal, non-commercial use only. Last updated: 10/13/2026.
Total Monthly Cost
$7,243/mo
NJ has the highest property taxes in the US. This is your real cost.
Down: $170,000 | Loan: $680,000
Estimates for informational purposes only. Insurance, maintenance, and flood costs are approximations. Consult a lender and insurance agent for accurate quotes.
Similar Properties in Butler Borough
$625,000

67 Halina Lane, Butler Borough, NJ, 07405
Butler Borough, NJ
Est. $5,249/mo total cost
Listed by Century 21 The Crossing
$750,000

56 Outlook Street, Butler Borough, NJ, 07405
Butler Borough, NJ
Est. $5,856/mo total cost
Listed by United Real Estate
$549,000

63 Terrace Avenue, Butler Borough, NJ, 07405
Butler Borough, NJ
Est. $4,552/mo total cost
Listed by Realty Executives Exceptional Realtors-Wayne
$615,000

14 Leonard Road, Butler Borough, NJ, 07405
Butler Borough, NJ
Est. $4,903/mo total cost
Listed by Coldwell Banker, Wayne

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the NJMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Green Team are marked with the NJMLS Internet Data Exchange logo and information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Some properties listed with the participating brokers do not appear on this website at the request of the seller. Listings of brokers that do not participate in Internet Data Exchange do not appear on this website.
This information is being provided for Consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties Consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Last date updated: 10/26/2026.
© 2026 New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.
Property listings provided by GardenState.ai through authorized access to NJMLS.
Brokerage: Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Green Team — 293 Route 94, Vernon, NJ 07462
Real Estate Agent: Julio Reynoso
GardenState.ai is an independent Artificial Intelligence platform. We are not affiliated with, sponsored by, or part of NJMLS.
All listings are displayed in accordance with IDX regulations of the State of New Jersey.
Equal Housing Opportunity. All real estate advertised herein is subject to the Federal Fair Housing Act, the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination, and applicable state and local fair housing laws, which make it illegal to advertise any preference, limitation, or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity, or any other protected class.