Butler Borough, NJ
Real Estate Market Report
Updated October 2026
10
Active Listings
7
Sold (3 months)
$676,804
Avg Sale Price
$640,000
Median Sale Price
$664,613
Avg List Price
N/A
Avg $/Sqft
5
Under Contract
📈 Prices Trending Up
Market Trend
Balanced Market — 4.3 months of inventory
Investment Analysis
Based on tax records, sales trends, and market data
77
Investment Score
Strong Buy
+3.5%
Price Appreciation
Last 3 months vs prior 3
$3,840
Est. Monthly Rent
Net yield: 5.1%/yr
$13,514
Avg Annual Tax
Median: $13,514.38
This tool is provided solely by Garden State AI and is not a product or service of BHG Green Team Realty. BHG Green Team Realty is not responsible for the accuracy of this AI-generated information.
Stay Ahead of the Butler Borough Market
Get instant alerts — new listings, price drops, and sold comps in Butler Borough.
Get Instant Price-Drop & New Listing Alerts in Butler Borough
Tell us when a Butler Borough home hits the market or drops in price. Free buyer alerts.
What's Your Butler Borough Home Worth in 2026?
Get a seller valuation for your Butler Borough home using recent sales and local tax data.
Recent Sales in Butler Borough
Last 3 months
SoldSold $816,000
Listed at $725,000
59 Outlook Street
Sold: Oct 19, 2026
Listed by: Ronald Aiosa, II, Keller Williams Prosperity Realty
Sold by: Elizabeth Hogan, Realty Executives Exceptional Realtors-Fairfield
SoldSold $835,500
Listed at $749,000
18 Dean Avenue
Sold: Oct 8, 2026
Listed by: James Hogan, Keller Williams Prosperity Realty
Sold by: Eileen Bassi, Prominent Properties Sotheby's International Realty-Franklin Lakes
SoldSold $590,000
Listed at $550,000
16 Argus Avenue
Sold: Sep 30, 2026
Listed by: Edwin Kalinka, Keller Williams Realty Metropolitan
Sold by: Colleen McMahon, Century 21 Crest Real Estate
SoldSold $640,000
Listed at $625,000
63 Valley Road
Sold: Sep 15, 2026
Listed by: Trina Olivo, Keller Williams Town Life
Sold by: Laura Piccoli, Realty Executives Exceptional Realtors-Pompton Plains
SoldSold $560,000
Listed at $534,700
102 Belleview Avenue
Sold: Sep 15, 2026
Listed by: Tina Cali, Century 21 Gemini Realty, LLC
Sold by: Renee Gialanella, Agency on the Ave, LLC
SoldSold $625,000
Listed at $609,000
81 Summit Avenue
Sold: Sep 10, 2026
Listed by: Judith Longo, Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate Green Team
Sold by: Maria Hernandez, Coldwell Banker, Clifton
Homes for Sale in Butler Borough
10 active listings
Active$850,000
71 Bartholdi Avenue
Listed by Howard Hanna Rand Realty
Active$765,000
46 Decker Avenue
Listed by Keller Williams Integrity
Active$750,000
56 Outlook Street
Listed by United Real Estate
Active$699,000
64 Valley Road
Listed by Realty One Group Paramount
Active$689,000
30 Center Street
Listed by Terrie O'Connor Realtors-Kinnelon
Active$640,000
20 Center Street
Listed by Prestige Property Group - Montclair
Own a Home in Butler Borough?
Find out what it's worth in today's market. Free, instant, no obligation.
Get My Free Home ValuationOr message Vale on WhatsApp: +1 (201) 528-1095